Compare and contrast Winters Bone and Captain Fantastic


Compare and contrast Winters Bone and Captain Fantastic



This essay will compare and contrast Winters Bone and Captain Fantastic. First of all, Winters Bone is an independent drama, whereas Captain Fantastic is a comedic drama, despite being different genre these films share similar elements.

Captain Fantastic tells the story of a family who live in the Washington wilderness due to their parents beliefs and raising their children as liberal activist, however due to circumstances they have to reintegrate into modern society. This film uses bright lighting throughout to imply that it is a happy place .The film uses the concept of different lifestyles to contrast  with others in the modern world, in the opening scene of this film uses mid-shots and long shots are used to represent the family. These types of shots are convenient because we get to see their surroundings as well as their actions, this allows the audience to establish their lifestyle.  Winters Bone does this as well, however, the setting is dismal and tracks are main character walking across the landscape. The dismal setting connotes to depression and tells us it’s not a happy place. Winters Bone also contrast different lifestyles but not in the same way ,instead it contrasts families by who they know and hierarchy in the film we see themes of this by the men characters  having power over females i.e. Gail is sometimes controlled by her husband and Merab has power due to her group.

Captain Fantastic uses simple mise en scène to mirror the characters lifestyle, for instants there clothing is very basic it does not portray an image that they are wealthy, however due to their lifestyle being shown to the audience we don’t associate the characters with poverty. Winters bone uses simple costumes but unlike captain fanatic, we do link them closely with poverty because the props used in the house are very minimal.

Both films use weaponry props for hunting, although in Winters Bone we see one setting the whole time ,so the audience gets a message that this a norm for them to hunt in this area and time period. The props are more modern as they use guns. On the other hand Captain Fantastic uses two different types of settings; the first setting is of the wilderness, where it seems completely normal to hunt deer’s with knives. However, later on when they visit family members the audience quickly notices it’s not a norm for the era they live in, it’s almost like the characters and the audience get a reality check but refused to accept that the Cash family doesn’t live a normal life.

Captain fantastic uses irony due to the names of characters, for example the character who plays the father who is implied to be captain fantastic name is Ben Cash ,it’s ironic because the family barely uses money for anything and does not agree with it due to their hatred towards capitalism.The two films are similar in terms of audio codes as there is very little additional sound added onto the narrative, this is unlike dramas as they tend to do this to add tension onto the scene , both films could have done this to highlight their simple lifestyles.


To conclude , the two films do share some of the same themes but they are not always portrayed in the same ways.

Comments

  1. Coulsdon A Level Film and Media10 December 2017 at 09:55

    Meghan you raise some very good points about the genre, themes and the micro features used by the Director and the creative teams to create meaning for their audience. However you have neglected to mention the Directors names or the dates the films were produced or released. Looking into the production context of these two films would strengthen your piece.
    However it is well written you need to continue to push yourself to create GREAT work every time. Well Done.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Analysis of Trainspotting opening,overdose and ending scene.

Image
Trainspotting opening scene analysis. Trainspotting is a 1996 British black comedy, that is directed by Danny Boyle and starring Ewan McGregor, Ewen Bremner, Jonny Lee Miller, Kevin McKidd, Robert Carlyle, and Kelly Macdonald . The film is based on the novel of the same name by Irvine Welsh; the film was released in the United Kingdom on 23 February 1996. In the opening scene of trainspotting we see Renton and spud running down the road, the camera movement and music merge together to match the action on screen. The music immediately starts playing once we see a low angled shot of our characters feet; this could link to how upbeat the characters lifestyle in their opinion. Furthermore when we see the car hit Renton is could be double meaning as throughout the narrative he talks about having a career, so, the car could signify the barrier of drug addiction that stops him having all the stuff mentioned. the positioning of the two characters could suggest that Renton is alwa
Read more

buster keaton

Buster Keaton: One Week, The Scarecrow, The High Sign, Cops Buster Keaton tends to use long shots to encourage the audience to look around the frame to see the joke, they allow an appreciation of the gag. Close ups usually follow up from this to show the characters reaction. He also tends to shoot face on so he is centre of attention. Keaton does this to highlight the idea that he is the joke and considered a clown; this tends to follow through on most films. In Cops there is a scene where Keaton is depicted in the foreground trying to take nap, a deep focus is used to show us that the city is unfurling in the background. Yet again Keaton is placed in the middle of the frame, this allows the audience to see how interacts with the chaotic and mechanical world. This is a very iconic use of cinematography for Keaton, as he tends to prefer to get everything in one frame, this is because editing in the 20s was considered as deceiving the audience. The sets used in Buster Keaton
Read more

Analysis of coin toss scenes in no country for old men.

Analysis of coin toss scenes in no country for old men The coin toss scenes are key elements of the film it they tell us vital points about Chigurh personality. The first coin toss scene is set in a small petrol station in the middle of nowhere a conversation between the cashier and  Chigurh seemed perfectly normal up until the point when the cashier mentioned that he saw him coming from Dallas. Chigurh then automatically makes the conversation heated we get this idea when he calls the shopkeeper “friendo”.  Chigurh continually asks the shopkeeper questions this gives the audience an uneasy feeling. Additionally  Chigurh is placed in front of the door, this emphasises that the shopkeeper is isolated and has no escape from this vicious killer. the shopkeeper wears traditional clothing that fits the location , mid shots are used to show this as we can see the secret of the landscape behind him.  Chigurh on the other hand juxtaposes this idea as he wears dark clothing which c
Read more